Grand Central Terminal and the Pershing Square Plaza bridge beneath surrounding Manhattan skyscrapers.

Weekly Manhattan & Brooklyn Market Update: 11/4

Elegran | Forbes Global Properties October 27, 2024

Momentum Slows Amid Rising Rates and Election Uncertainty

The Manhattan and Brooklyn real estate markets are facing headwinds as mortgage rates have again surpassed 7%, jumping nearly 80 basis points since mid-September. Coupled with the uncertainty surrounding the upcoming election, market activity has softened, with some buyers and sellers opting to pause their plans.

In Manhattan, inventory decreased slightly, with 30% fewer new listings and 19% fewer signed contracts than the previous week. Brooklyn also experienced a downturn, with supply shrinking by over 1%, new listings dropping 30%, and signed contracts declining 14% week-over-week.

Consumer sentiment cooled this week, as evidenced by the Elegran | Forbes Global Properties Consumer Sentiment Index, which fell from +48 to +20. 

For the week ahead, expectations remain cautious, with the election expected to dominate public focus. Nevertheless, there is room for optimism: buyer activity will likely rebound as the political landscape settles and interest rates decline. However, with supply projected to remain tight through the winter, the early spring market may become more competitive, driven by a rise in demand outpacing the replenishment of inventory.

Chart of NYC consumer sentiment, plunging in early 2020 and rising above the pre-pandemic average in 2021.

Manhattan Supply

Manhattan saw a slight decrease in supply this week, with 6,846 units currently available for sale. Only 241 new listings were introduced, causing overall inventory to decrease by 0.2% compared to last week. New listings also sharply declined, dropping 30% from the prior week and 32% year-over-year. 

Line chart of Manhattan housing supply from 2020 to 2024, fluctuating between roughly 5,600 and 10,400 listings.

Data courtesy of UrbanDigs

Brooklyn Supply

Brooklyn’s supply also contracted this week, with 3,383 units currently available for sale, marking a 1.3% decrease from the previous week. Only 121 new listings came onto the market, reflecting a 30% drop from last week and an even steeper 49% decline compared to the same period last year.

Brooklyn housing supply chart, showing a general decline from a late-2020 peak above 5,000 to about 3,400 in 2024.

Data courtesy of UrbanDigs

Manhattan Pending Sales: Pending sales rose by 1.8%, reaching 2,810 units, continuing the upward momentum of the fall season.

Brooklyn Pending Sales: Pending sales increased by 1.9% to 1,872 units.

Manhattan Consumer Sentiment

Contract activity in Manhattan slowed this week, with only 192 contracts signed—a nearly 20% decline from the previous week. Despite this drop, the number of contracts signed still represents a 28% increase compared to the same week last year. The Elegran | Forbes Global Properties Manhattan Consumer Sentiment Index declined from +21 to -1 this week.

Bar chart of Manhattan consumer sentiment, showing a sharp pandemic decline and later fluctuations around the pre-pandemic average.

Brooklyn Consumer Sentiment

Brooklyn saw a slowdown in contract activity this week, with only 136 contracts signed, marking a 14% decrease from the previous week. However, this figure is still 11% higher than the same week last year. The Elegran | Forbes Global Properties Brooklyn Consumer Sentiment Index fell from +105 to 77%.

Brooklyn consumer sentiment chart: scores plunge in spring 2020, then fluctuate mostly above the pre-pandemic average.

New Development Insights 

Marketproof reported that 54 new development contracts were signed in 41 buildings this week. The following buildings were the top-selling new developments of the week:

- The Huron (Greenpoint) signed 5 contracts

- One Wall Street (Financial District) and Monogram New York (Turtle Bay) each signed 3 contracts.

Let's Work Together

Her experience, expertise, and engaging personality make Sonal the perfect combination of advisor, advocate, and strategist. She is the proud owner of several NYC properties and a skilled negotiator with a deep understanding of people and sharp instincts about market trends.